We intend to use this page for general planning issues such as guidance on how to comment on planning applications and other issues our members ask us about.
You will find news items concerned with planning either on the front page of the website or in the News section.
Commenting on a planning application
0 Introduction
Members of the Society, and others, often contact us asking how they can comment on a nearby planning application, usually one they have found out about by seeing a yellow notice posted on a lamp post. Comments can be made in support or in objection. As members will know from our regular updates, a small group of us reviews and, where appropriate, comments on all major applications such as Perceval House and other significant applications in conservation areas and occasionally individual householder applications.
The planning system can be daunting. Applications range from major developments that can involve vocal local campaigns to small home extensions that may have a huge effect on the immediate neighbourhood. We have produced this brief guide to assist our members, particularly with regard to the latter.
Over the past few years, it seems that planners have grown far more supportive of new developments and less attentive to the views of local communities who are uncomfortable about the way their neighbourhood is changing. For this reason, you might find it very difficult indeed to persuade the planner dealing with a case to see things your way.
Do not get too disheartened. In many cases a new development may improve your area by raising the standard of housing stock and improving gardens and landscape – this may be better than land and buildings in your neighbourhood remaining in a rundown state.
1 How to find out about an application
The first most people know about a new application is when they see a yellow notice fixed to a lamp post (see picture). The Council no longer notifies neighbouring properties by letter. The notice will give the address concerned, brief details of the application, a reference number and QR code which can be used to access details of the full application on the Council’s website.
More detail about Ealing’s notification process can be found in the code of practice for neighbour notification.
Tips
The yellow lamp post notices advertising an application are not necessarily displayed on the nearest lamp post to the property concerned or where all affected residents will pass them; for example, those living on a street to the rear of a plot to be developed may be affected but no notices may be displayed.
Keep an eye on these notices. Sometimes they are not removed for a considerable period, but sometimes they are, only to be replaced by another notice about a different proposal. It is easy to miss the change and a new proposal may be one that affects you more.
The LBE planning website, known as PAM, may be searched using various identifiers such as the post code, the first line of the address or the planning application reference number from the notice. See image below.
You can also use the Council’s planning website to look at the weekly or monthly lists of all planning applications in the Borough or in a particular ward in case you are interested in commenting on some of the major development proposals.
You will normally be given 21 days to lodge any comments, and any comments submitted in this period will be considered, but comments may still be made up to the time that an application is determined, at which point PAM locks out further comments.
Remember that not all changes to a property require planning permission. Rules, known as ‘permitted development’ rights, allow an owner to make some changes to a property without needing to apply for planning permission if specific limitations and conditions are met. The right of objection to permitted development proposals, however unsuitable or poorly designed, is very limited and dependent on the exact nature of the application.
Each application will have a planning officer allocated to it. Contacting these officers can be difficult as they do not have published email addresses or telephone numbers (but the Council switchboard on 020 8825 5000 may disclose their email addresses). If you are able to establish contact details, it may be possible to ask questions directly of the planning officer, but some may not be prepared to respond.
2 How to comment
You should submit your comments online via the planning website. You can email the planning department (useful if you wish to submit a very long objection or to attach supporting photos or other documents), or in writing if you do not have access to a computer, but we cannot guarantee such comments will be taken into account. You will need to give your name and address and ideally to send your comments within 21 days of the start of the consultation period. Your comments will be visible and cannot be made anonymously. Until recently, both your name and address were shown with the comment, but currently (February 2022) only the address is shown.
Tips
If you have a lengthy objection letter, and if you wish to include photos or other documents, submit these by email to the planning department asking for confirmation of receipt and that they are uploaded in full to the documents section of the application website. Check that this is done. Also, submit a summary online objection to boost the number of objections.
The official time period to respond to an application is just three weeks from the date of notification, which can be challenging, particularly for large applications with many published documents. In practice, comments can be submitted up to the point at which planning officers make a decision, so do not feel you are ‘too late’ to submit. However, officers will have started to form their own opinion, and to draft their report at an earlier stage, so if comments are submitted at a late stage in the process, they may not carry as much weight as comments submitted earlier and the die may well have been cast.
If you are objecting to a proposal in your immediate neighbourhood, inform your neighbours what is proposed and how to access the application as they probably won’t be aware of the application and may also want to object. Get them to support you to demonstrate that there is real local concern. If you don’t know many people on your street, a good way to do this is by designing a simple leaflet, or you could set up a neighbourhood WhatsApp group to share information and communicate quickly and easily. Discuss your concerns with your neighbours and try to agree on the key points you want to object to. Try to avoid using a standard form of words or a petition, as these tend to have limited impact. It doesn’t always work, but the more local people who object to a development the greater chance you will have of getting the officer dealing with the case to take notice of you.
Contact your local ward councillors and ask them to visit the site with you and to support your objections by submitting an objection themselves. Note that any councillor who sits on the planning committee will not get involved, as they must not form an opinion before committee. Also ask them that should the application not be refused, they request its referral to committee for determination rather than being granted on officers’ delegated powers. This is not automatic and may still be refused by the committee chair.
3 Grounds for objection
Take care in preparing your objection, as it will be your main opportunity to influence the outcome of the application. Only planning-related comments will be considered, so your objections should relate to at least one of the following issues:
- Design, layout, bulk and density of building(s)
- External appearance and materials
- Access for disabled people
- Loss of daylight, sunlight and privacy as a result of overshadowing or overlooking
- Noise and disturbance, hazardous waste, smells caused by use
- Traffic generation, road safety, access and parking issues plus space for loading and turning
- Loss of, or an increase in, a particular type of use of land, including nature conservation, landscaping, archaeology, and the effect on a listed building and conservation area (where appropriate)
- For residential development, appropriate provision of affordable housing and both private and external amenity space.
A number of broader planning issues will also be taken into account so it is worth referencing relevant local, strategic, regional and national planning policies[1]. If you know of any previous planning decisions that help your case, you should cite these as precedent.
The Council will not take into account:
- Loss of a view
- Effect on property values
- The likely impact of building work
- The motives or behaviour of the applicant
- Whether the proposal conflicts with a legal covenant.
Note that special rules can apply in conservation areas. More information can be found in the management plan for the relevant conservation area and the (new) generic management plan that relates to all conservation areas.
Tips
It can be beneficial to employ the services of a planning consultancy to review the application and to write your objection letter for you. They will be able to interpret the submitted details, see where there are omissions or inaccuracies and ensure the objection is firmly based on planning policy and relevant matters rather than points planners will not take into consideration. They can also take photos of your location and include the outlines of proposed buildings to show how the plans affect your building (but note that using such professionals can be an expensive cost). Other specialists, such as an arboriculturist, can also be employed to challenge other reports submitted by an applicant in support of their claim – these are not always very accurate!
When you submit an online objection to an application, you have the option to ‘track’ the application. Click on that option to receive an advice by email if there are any material changes to the application or when a decision is made. There is no requirement for the Council to reconsult when plans change but using tracking allows you to comment further if you wish. However, the process is not fool proof; some changes do not seem to be picked up by tracking and sometimes you can be advised when there are no apparent changes. The addition of comments from others is not tracked so it is worth checking regularly to see what others are saying.
There may be covenants in title deeds relating to the application site defining historic restrictions on its use or development, for example, to use only as a single dwelling. Note that these are not relevant matters that will be taken into consideration when determining a planning application but may be pursued (at cost) through the legal system, when compensation may sometimes be awarded for a breach.
4 The determination process
The process of considering an application and any comments received and making a decision on the outcome – to grant or refuse – is known as determination.
Each application is considered by a planning officer who will assess the proposals against relevant planning policy. There may be dialogue between the officer and applicant where the officer may point out aspects of the application that are unacceptable and could lead to a refusal. Changes to proposals may be requested, which can sometimes lead to significant revisions. A weakness in the present process is that in most cases, unless the application is a major one and the changes are considered significant, objectors are not notified of the changes and there is no reconsultation. It is therefore worth keeping an eye on applications of interest in case revised plans or additional documents have been made available.
Most applications are supposed to be determined within 8 weeks of acceptance (validation) by the Council, but in reality, decisions are rarely made within that timescale and may often take many months or even years with little obvious progress.
Most decisions are taken on officers’ delegated powers, which means that the planning officer will produce a decision report explaining how they have reached their decision. For major schemes, or where a request is made to the planning committee chair by a ward councillor and accepted by the chair, an application can be forwarded for determination by the planning committee. The officer still assesses the application and produces a decision report, but this is only a recommendation to committee and the committee can either accept it or overturn it. In theory, a planning committee could consider recommendations either to grant or refuse but in practice a recommendation to refuse is unlikely to be referred to committee.
If you have objected to an application that is then referred to committee, you will be notified and will be asked if you would like to speak at the committee meeting. Normally, only one objector may speak, and is allowed up to three minutes, with the applicant also allowed the same time to speak in support of their application. There is no right to question the applicant. A ward councillor may also ask to speak either in support of or against a proposal and is given up to five minutes; it is therefore well worth a group of objectors lining up a councillor to add their voice at this stage.
The planning committee can grant or refuse an application, suggest additional conditions to be attached to a grant, or defer the decision to a later committee if further detail is required before a decision can be taken. In most cases, once an application is approved, this decision is final and cannot be challenged. Only the applicant has the right of appeal (to the Planning Inspectorate) against a refusal; there is no right of appeal by a third party.
Many major applications in the Borough are also subject to approval by the Mayor of London and, very occasionally, applications can be ‘called in’ by the Secretary of State (for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities) for determination through a public inquiry held by a planning inspector.
Tips
If the application is to be determined at committee, register to speak in opposition, which allows you to deliver a three minute speech – not long, but enough to concentrate on the key planning issues. Also ask one of your councillors to speak as they are allowed five minutes,
[1] The group Ealing Matters has prepared a useful summary of these.
Planning for the Future
In August 2020 the government issued a White Paper entitled Planning for the Future. The White Paper proposed “reforms of the planning system to streamline and modernise the planning process, bring a new focus to design and sustainability, improve the system of developer contributions to infrastructure, and ensure more land is available for development where it is needed”. There was a 12 week consultation period. The Society’s response to the White Paper may be read here.