How well is Ealing Civic Society doing on behalf of its members and the borough?

posted in: Miscellaneous | 0

That is a difficult question to ask of oneself but perhaps a starting point is to compare how Ealing Civic Society (ECS) is doing compared to others. There are said to be roughly 750 civic societies in the UK, ranging in membership size from as few as 10 to over 1,300 members (data based on a 2011 survey by Historic England). ECS membership is not large compared to the size of the borough, but our research shows that we certainly do punch above our weight in what we do.

Asking that question prompted two pieces of research and analysis which were undertaken by committee members Philippa Dolphin and John Boult. The smaller survey looked at how civic societies communicate, particularly in a digital age, with members and others. We studied the websites of a small sample of civic societies. The choice of sample was a combination of random selection, societies that were known to us, and societies in other London areas. There was no real evidence of any specific non-digital communication for the societies we looked at, but many newsletters / annual reports were designed to look like printed matter rather than online communications. However digital communication was generally embraced enthusiastically. A second part of the study looked at the social media platforms used by younger audiences. Instagram or similar obvious platforms were clearly shown to be needed if we wish to engage with a younger demographic. ECS was no different from most civic societies in its use of Facebook, X, YouTube or email, but unlike some others we did not use Instagram. We do now….

The larger study looked at London’s civic societies and catalogued all the activities they did or claimed to do. Firstly the list is extremely ‘rich’ in type and nature of activities,  and also diverse in how they realise and pursue those activities. Unsurprisingly societies approached their purpose or aims in different ways, no doubt a reflection on the geographic location and its challenges and, of course, the interests and skillsets of the membership and committees.

The following is a list of all the activities identified in the survey and the number of societies which claimed to actively pursue that particular activity (shown as a percentage)..

WHAT SOCIETIES IN THE SURVEY DO

Activity % undertaking this activity
Planning focus 69%
Environment focus 50%
Built heritage 53%
Plaques 12%
Awards 19%
Events 16%
Talks, trips & social events 41%
Interesting approaches 19%
Newsletter 31%

 

Ealing Civic Society is unique in this survey as the only society that actively pursues all those activities.

What the research suggests is that ECS is actually doing a lot of things, where others are not. Are we doing those things better (than others) or effectively (the best we can do)? That is a far harder question to answer, but we are always open to suggestions. Gratifying research but no room for complacency as we need to learn and move forward. We do all this with a very few committee members, and could do a lot more if we had more people who could help, for example looking at planning and licensing applications.

John Boult