Latest planning work

posted in: Planning | 0

Our Environment Subcommittee has been working hard to review planning applications on your behalf. Amongst this batch of 12 objections and comments are two applications which we are pleased to see have been withdrawn, which makes the effort worthwhile.  They may of course reappear in a modified form.

Existing Substation On Lynwood, Rear Of 1-4 Western Avenue, Ealing, W5 1JL

Construction of a two-storey building, with habitable loft space, to accommodate 2 self-contained residential units and provision of associated parking space (following demolition of existing Substation)

We objected to this application, which represented overdevelopment of the brownfield site, and made suggestions as to how it could be improved. Over 100 objections were received before the application was withdrawn, suggesting that the applicant was possibly advised to rethink.

Ealing Civic Society supports the principle of making use of this redundant brownfield site to provide housing.  However, we object to the proposals in their current form.  The attempt to provide two houses on the site results in overdevelopment and an incongruous design.  The addition of a further storey produces an over-high and disproportionate structure.  It appears also that necessary internal space and amenity space standards are not met.  Further work is needed to the proposal to create a single, two storey property compliant with interior space and external amenity space standards.  For comparison, we would reference the conversion of a similar redundant sub-station at 1A Ashbourne Road W5 to a single dwelling, achieved without the need to raise the roof height.

 

Workshop & Land Between Hanson Gardens And Lewis Road, Southall, UB1 1BP

Residential redevelopment comprising three single storey detached houses; four x two storey detached houses and a two storey building comprising two flats; associated landscaping, cycle parking, refuse storage and access (Following demolition of existing buildings)

We objected to this application, the second for the backland site. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We note the planned reduction in the overall height of the development in comparison with that of a previous application for the site.  However, we maintain that the proposals continue to be inappropriate overdevelopment on this location.  We consider the proposed design of the buildings to be too blocky and, as such, very unsympathetic to the neighbouring houses.  In addition, we maintain our concerns about the loss of biodiversity from the location through the removal of mature trees and lack of soft landscaping.  Furthermore, we continue to object to the planned access to the development which the applicant concedes would be too narrow for refuse vehicles to enter.  Presumably, then, emergency vehicles would be denied access, thus presenting potential safety issues with this constrained site.  A development of lower density would be far more appropriate for this location and we urge the Council to respond to the applicant accordingly.

 

The Old Fire Station And Stable Block, Longfield Avenue, Ealing, W5 2UQ

Change of use from commercial (Use Class E) and conversion to provide 8no. residential units (Use Class C3) including lowering of the existing basement; creation of roof dormers to the front and rear of the fire station building, rooflights on the stable block and minor repair and replacement works; with associated private amenity spaces, and provision of refuse storage

We objected to this application to convert these historic buildings in the north-west corner of Dickens Yard to residential use, making a number of detailed suggestions for changes. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society has discussed our initial objections to these proposals with St George and we maintain our objections to some aspects of the proposals.  We have no objection in principle to the redesignation of these now empty locally-listed buildings as residential accommodation.  However, we do not agree with St George that the external changes are all sensitive to the character of the buildings.  In particular, the proposed removal of the chimney to the Fire Station building and the proposed dormers on the elevation facing Longfield Avenue – intended to enhance the living conditions in the new flats – are not acceptable in the Conservation Area.  The Council’s presumption is against removal of chimney stacks in a Conservation Area.  We understand that no internal fireplaces remain; any remaining chimney breasts can be removed internally to create space, but the chimney itself needs to be retained and supported.  Secondly, although we note that the current roof lights on the elevation facing Longfield Avenue are not original, we are unconvinced that the proposed dormers would be an improvement on good quality conservation roof lights, particularly in a utilitarian or industrial type of building like this.  The proportions of the proposed dormers are not in keeping with the dimensions of the roof but, if to be adopted, thought should be given to possibly making them narrower.  Thirdly, although the proposed low hedging offers some privacy to the front garden spaces, we consider that simple railings would be more in keeping with the industrial feel of the host structures.  If the Council is minded to approve this application, we suggest that the approval includes a condition that the boundary treatment to the front amenity spaces is maintained by St George to ensure that it remains a tidy and landscaped area and that residents are similarly required to maintain the amenity spaces in a tidy condition.  Finally, we would like to see a condition attached to ensure that the former fire station tower continues to be maintained and that the decorative stained glass windows are illuminated after dark as has been the case in the past.

Cecelia House, 16-17 Hanger Lane, Ealing, W5 3HH

Refurbishment and extension of existing House in Multiple Occupation (31 HMO units – Use Class Sui Generis) to provide 74 self contained co-living apartments with a common kitchen/dining room, for use as private rental sector accommodation, secured in perpetuity by way of a legal agreement (Use Class Sui Generis). (Outline application)

We objected to this application for extension and conversion of a single property to provide 74 co-living apartments, a clear example of overdevelopment. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects strongly to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment and lack of compliance with nationally and regionally prescribed space standards.  The proposed size of the rooms is significantly below national standards and most of these rooms would be single aspect.  The planned inclusion of some (35%) of intermediate affordable units does not make this small size acceptable.  If granted, this would contribute to the proliferation of substandard accommodation in the borough.

 

45 The Broadway, Ealing, W5 5JU

Redevelopment of existing site (ground floor bank and offices above – Use Class A2/B1a); construction of part three, part four storey extension to existing building and a five storey extension to the rear for use as nine residential dwellings (Use Class C3) two commercial and business units (Use Class E(a,b,c,g(i)); ancillary use at basement level (following partial demolition of the existing building)

We objected to this large and out-of-keeping proposal for development over the Lloyds Bank building on The Broadway in the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  The site sits within the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area and, as such, any development here should be in keeping with its environs.  With the over-bulky and over-tall buildings planned, this proposal would instead represent harmful overdevelopment in the Conservation Area.  Therefore, we consider that the proposed re-development should be re-designed so that it incorporates traditional Victorian-style fenestration with brick and stone materials used rather than the planned large expanses of glazed windows, metal “pergola” structures and metal cladding.  In addition, the height of the building should be reduced to no greater than four storeys to the north, with the uppermost storey set back from the lower structure in order to reduce its apparent bulk from the ground, and stepping down to the south.  Finally, we were particularly disappointed that, in pre-application discussion, the applicant appears to have been encouraged by Council officers to design a building that would be out of keeping within the Conservation Area, which is contrary to the Council’s own policies.

 

134-136 Broadway, West Ealing, W13 0TL

Construction of sixth floor to accommodate three additional self-contained residential units to previously approved scheme ref: 183569FUL granted on appeal ref: APP/A5270/W/19/3227828 dated 23/03/ 2020 for: Construction of a part five-storey and part six-storey building comprising 19 flats, 17 x one bedroom, 1 x two bedroom and 1 x studio; A1 shop unit on ground floor (following demolition of the existing buildings)

We objected to this further application for this site, proposing additional storeys on an already over height building. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  This application is yet another example of an incremental approach being taken to applications, whereby second and third applications proposing additional accommodation are made, rather than the true intentions of the applicant being transparent from the start.  This approach should be rejected by planning officers and for this reason alone, this application should be refused.  As we pointed out in our previous objection, we consider that the approved (on appeal) development is already too high, especially since the massing of the consented building when viewed from the front would significantly exceed the height of its neighbours.  The overall appearance would already be far too dominant on to the Broadway in West Ealing.  The proposed additional sixth/seventh floor would exacerbate this overbearing appearance and further contribute to already unacceptable overdevelopment of the site.  The additional storey on each block would also further contribute to overshadowing of the ground level courtyard amenity space and the windows of the flats at lower levels.

The impact of the proposals on several neighbouring locally listed assets, particularly the Halfway House pub just two properties to the west, which we consider to be a key character contributor on the Broadway, and the two properties at numbers 130 and 132 to the east, has not been properly considered.  The proposed development will already detract from these properties and the additional storey will compound this.

We note that planning officers resisted the development of the 5-and 6-storey building at pre-application stage and we would urge officers to maintain this position in relation to this further proposed increase in height and reject this application.

 

Land Between Rosebank Way and Leamington Park, Rosebank Way, Acton, W3 6XZ

Construction of a part 6 storey , part 5 storey building to accommodate 23 self-contained flats and provision of two commercial units (Use Class E)

We submitted comments on this new development, which has an interesting design and would provide much needed 3-bed accommodation. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society notes with approval the proposed inclusion of 52% of 3-bedroom units, which are rarely provided for in such developments.  However, we raise concerns about the lack of any detail at this stage of the planning process on the affordable accommodation provision.  We have been seeking clarity on this aspect since the initial public ‘consultation’ and would have expected this application to include a proposal for affordable accommodation in line with the local plan and local need.  Given the dearth of 3-bedroom units across the borough, we recommend that these are included as part of the affordable housing offer.

 

5-21 Bollo Bridge Road, Acton, W3 8AT

Construction of a part five, part six and part seven storey residential development comprising 44 flats; a terrace of three x 3 storey mews houses; associated parking and cycle parking facilities (Following demolition of the existing building)

We objected to this application, which has also received a large number of local objections. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  While we acknowledge that redevelopment of the unsightly builder’s yard currently on the site would be an improvement, we consider that this proposal would result in unacceptable overdevelopment.  The planned scheme would be far too tall for its environs and out of keeping with its neighbours, especially those to the north.  The proposed design is utilitarian and lacks local context.  We also note that views from the north of the successful warehouse conversion, now Chiswick View, on the other side of the railway would be obscured and the height of the proposals would mean that the properties at Chiswick View are overshadowed.  We note that our concerns are in-line with those raised at the pre-application stage regarding the bulk and height of the proposal, which do not appear to have been addressed by the applicant despite several design iterations.

We note the applicant’s view that it is unviable to provide any affordable housing within the development; this is unacceptable and a minimum of 35% should be provided.

A more sympathetic proposal for use of the site would be the provision of a small development of family houses (as is suggested at the western end), each with adequate external private amenity space and off-street parking, which would contribute to meeting housing need and be in keeping with the local neighbourhood.

 

48 Inglis Road, Ealing, W5 3RW

Construction of a three storey building to accommodate 9 self-contained flats ( following demolition of existing building) and associated landscaping, refuse and car and cycle parking and associated works.

We objected to this proposal in the Creffield Conservation Area to demolish a bungalow and replace it with flats. The Conservation Area panel and local residents’ association have also strongly objected to the loss of the existing building of architectural merit. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We object to the demolition of the existing building, which we consider to be of architectural merit.  We acknowledge the statement in the Creffield Conservation Area (CA) Management Plan (p6) that “contemporary and modernist styles are entirely acceptable if they are high in quality and provided that they remain sympathetic in the context and towards the host building and/or other neighbouring buildings.”  However, we believe that the planned design of the proposed three storey building would not be sympathetic in the context and would significantly detract from the character of the Creffield CA and, therefore, be unacceptable.  Most of the immediate neighbours to this site are Victorian properties and, unlike the existing building, this proposal would be incongruous among them.  In addition, we object most strongly to the planned loss of mature trees from the site.  For instance, we do not accept the applicant’s justification for removing horse chestnut trees; leaf miner can be managed and trees with canker can survive for many years.

 

1 Northfield Road, West Ealing, W13 9SY

Construction of a three storey building, with roof garden, to accommodate 6 self-contained flats, including associated refuse and cycle facilities (following demolition of existing building)

We objected to this over height and over dense application. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment.  The height and positioning of the building right on the pavement would result in its being overbearing on the street scene and the proposed design would be totally out-of-keeping with its neighbours, particularly the properties on Northfield Road.  In addition, it is not clear that the planned internal layout would meet the national space standards that Ealing Council has adopted.  Insufficient amenity space is proposed; the private balconies would be far too small and the proposed roof garden would be unsuitable.  Furthermore, the presence of the staircase enclosure is an unsightly addition contributing to the excessive height of the building.

 

4 The Mall, Ealing, W5 2PJ (212142FUL)

Change of use of residential unit on first and second floor (Use Class C3) into a Large House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) (Use Class Sui Generis) comprising six bedrooms; first floor side/rear infill extension; second floor rear extension; rear roof extension to main roofslope incorporating balcony with glazed privacy screens on second floor; and installation of two rooflights to front roofslope

We objected to this proposal to convert this property into an HMO, offering small and substandard accommodation in Ealing Town Centre. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds that we do not believe that the proposal would provide suitable accommodation for future occupants given the very small size of the units.  If the Council is minded to approve this application, it would need to be satisfied there would be adequate refuse and recycling management arrangements in place and suitable means of escape in case of fire.

 

98 Gordon Road, West Ealing, W13 8PJ

Conversion of existing house into 9 self-contained flats; part single, part two storey rear and side (wraparound) extension (following demolition of existing additions); conversion of roof space into habitable space including installation of rooflights and dormer windows

We objected to this application to extend and convert a large Victorian family house into 9 flats on grounds of excessive massing and design issues. The application has been withdrawn.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We particularly object to aspects of the planned design, including what we consider to be an excessive use of flat roofs in an area of typically pitched clay-tiled roofs.  This design would give rise to uncomfortable bulk and massing and would result in unacceptable overdevelopment.  In addition, we object to the planned loss of the important corner gable wall with its decorative chimney breast.  The proposed extension replacing a former garage at this front eastern side should be set back from the corner in order to retain the subordinate characteristic.  Furthermore, the planned positioning of one of the roof windows hard up to the pinnacle roof would be completely out of place, visually and should be placed more symmetrically.