Our latest planning work

posted in: Planning | 0

We look at all planning applications submitted to the Council.  We then submit comments and objections about major schemes if we believe they are unsuitable. Here is our latest work.

11 Montpelier Avenue, W5 2XP

Conversion of existing building (3 residential units ) into 10 self-contained flats (4 x 1 bedroom, 5 x 2 bedroom and 1 x 3 bedroom); single-storey side/rear (wrap around) extension, following demolition of exiting garage; first floor rear extension, including the creation of a terrace/balcony; first floor side extension; rear roof extension, side roof extension, insertion of a bigger window to the front gable end and installation of three roof lights to front roof slope (Major Development)

We planned to object to this application which extended a previously approved one by the addition of a further flat. However, the application was withdrawn before we submitted our objection, possibly as the applicant would have been advised that a ten-flat development would trigger the threshold for affordable housing provision.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We are extremely disappointed that the planning officer did not appear to take into account our November 2019 comments when granting the previous application.  We maintain our view that this scheme would be overdevelopment.  In addition, if the Council is minded to approve this application, we would recommend the following changes:

  • The windows of the front elevation of the single storey elevation should match the style of the remaining front windows;
  • The flat roof to this single storey extension should be replaced with a pitched roof in order to remain in keeping with the rest of the house style;
  • Some or all of the existing chimneys should be retained to maintain the character of the roofscape;
  • The proposed replacement for the gable window is oversized and would be improved by being circular rather than square;
  • Since the property overlooks and is visible from the Montpelier Park Conservation Area, the proposed rooflights should be of conservation style.

London Borough of Ealing Perceval House, 14-16 Uxbridge Road, W5 2HL

Demolition of existing buildings and phased redevelopment of the site to provide a mixed-use development comprising residential, office, civic/community uses and flexible non-residential floor space, below ground ancillary space (plant, car and cycle parking space, etc.), replacement and relocation of the existing sub-station, associated enabling landscape and public realm works and provision of new pedestrian and vehicle access. (Regulation 3 Application by London Borough of Ealing)

Along with many other amenity groups and individuals, we objected to this proposed major overdevelopment.

Ealing Civic Society objects to a number of aspects of this proposed development, which in summary we consider would cause substantial and unacceptable harm to the surrounding area and heritage assets, is of inadequate design quality and does not adhere to aspects of planning policy.

Impact of tall building on heritage assets & distant views

The mass and height in particular of the 26 storey rear block would in our view cause substantial harm to heritage assets neighbouring the development site, namely:

  • Grade II listed Ealing Town Hall, particularly on the setting of the Town Hall when viewed towards the north-west from New Broadway;
  • Grade II* listed Christ the Saviour Church when looking towards the west from Ealing Broadway;
  • General views to the north-west from within the Ealing Town Centre conservation area; and
  • Locally listed former Ealing Fire Station, Longfield Avenue immediately opposite the site.

The impact can be clearly seen from the various visual impact assessments which accompany the application, in particular Views 3 & 4. Also, and arguably more damagingly, the block would intrude negatively in distant views looking north (View 9) from the Grade II* listed bridge in Walpole Park designed by Sir John Soane c 1800.

Although we note that Historic England takes the view that the harm to heritage assets would amount to less than substantial in policy terms, we would respectfully suggest that they underestimate this harm and we consider it to likely to be substantial in practice . We do not believe that this substantial harm could ever be outweighed by any alleged public benefits deriving from the scheme (policies 194 and 196 of the NPPF refer). We also agree with Historic England that the degree of harm would be exacerbated by the proposed appearance of the building, in particular the  prominent vertical red stripe on the East elevation which would serve to increase the presence and dominance of this building in view 3 in the context of Christ the Saviour Church. At the very least, the height of the building should be reduced in order to reduce its dominance in the landscape.

Design elements: cantilevered front block; alignment of Uxbridge Road frontage

We consider the design of the proposed cantilevered front block, together with the large area of glazing, to be unsympathetic and out of keeping with that of the Gothic style Grade II listed Ealing Town Hall immediately opposite to the East. We would wish the cantilevered element to be omitted which would have the benefit of removing the proposed arcaded area with its unattractive open space which is likely to be uninviting and windblown in anything other than very clement weather.

Furthermore, the frontage of the front block as proposed would be bought forward of the existing building line of Perceval House which would not be consistent with the “office corridor” concept set out in the Local Plan (policy 2.5(e)) and the Central Ealing Neighbourhood plan (policy HBE2). Both policies envisage an “increase in the number of street trees, other planting and active ground floor frontages” and the proposed development would thwart this ambition.

Conflict of interest

We understand from discussions with the developer that the overall quantum of development, in particular the height of the tallest block, has been driven entirely by the degree of development required in order to deliver the extent of affordable housing sought by the Council and its ambition to provide Council offices and associated facilities including the relocated Central Library and Customer Service Centre at no cost to the Council taxpayer. Since the Council, acting in its capacity as the local Planning Authority, will be determining the planning application and at the same time has a financial interest in the outcome it will be facing a conflict of interest. For this reason we consider that the final decision should be taken out of the Council’s hands and taken by the Secretary of State.

Arden Road Car Park, Corner of Arden Road & Uxbridge Road, W13 8RP

Construction of a part 8 storey, part 6 storey and part 4 storey building comprising 29 residential units (Use Class C3) and a commercial unit (Use Class E) at ground floor, along with refuse storage, cycle parking storage, plant rooms, communal roof terrace on the fourth floor and associated private amenity space; provision of 9 car parking spaces; and associated alterations to the public realm along Arden Road and Uxbridge Road. (Regulation 3 Application by London Borough of Ealing)

We objected to the proposed development by the Council on this West Ealing car park and also that at Dean Gardens (see next application).  The design of both schemes is poor and they are overdevelopments.

Ealing Civic Society object to this application.  We are extremely disappointed that the applicant does not appear to have taken into account our comments to the pre-application community consultation.  We maintain our objections as follows:

We consider that the proposed development would be out of keeping with the surrounding area by reason of its height and massing.  Firstly, the planned footprint does not respect the boulevard nature of the Uxbridge Road corridor – the new building would be set far too close to the road and should be set back to reflect the building line of the neighbouring church.  No consideration has been made to preserve views of the important heritage asset of the locally listed Fire Station.  The proposed building would also be much too high and over bulky in relation to its immediate neighbours – two and three storey houses.  Rather than offering an opportunity to enhance the community garden to the north of the site as suggested in the proposals, the construction of a 7/8 storey building would block all sunlight from the garden making it unsustainable as a growing space and unattractive as a ‘green oasis’.  In addition, the planned materials would be unsympathetic to those used elsewhere this vicinity.

Furthermore, we have concerns about the planned mix of accommodation.  There is already an over-supply of one- and two-bedroom flats in Ealing.  Any development on this site should provide much needed three-bedroom family units.

Maitland Yard & Dean Gardens Car Parks, South of Pioneer Court, Leeland Mansions & The Lodge, Dean Gardens, Leeland Terrace, W13 9AW

Construction of a 4 storey building, a 6 storey building and an 8 storey building, with lower ground floors, comprising 53 residential units in total (Use Class C3) and a commercial unit along Uxbridge Road (Use Class E), along with refuse storage, cycle parking storage and plant rooms; and associated alterations to the site access and public realm comprising landscaping, car parking and public amenity spaces to Maitland Yard and along Leeland Terrace. (Following demolition of existing building). (Regulation 3 Application by London Borough of Ealing)

Ealing Civic Society object to this application.  We are extremely disappointed that the Council did not appear to have taken into account our comments to the pre-application community consultation.  We maintain our objections as follows:

We consider that the proposed development would be out of keeping with the surrounding area.  The planned design is unimaginative and characterless and would not reflect the local vernacular.  The proposals represent overdevelopment and in particular, the proposed blocks would be far too high and the materials do not appear to complement the red brick of the neighbouring buildings.

In addition, we have concerns about the planned mix of accommodation.  There is already an over-supply of one- and two-bedroom flats in Ealing.  Any development on this site should comprise a predominance of much needed three-bedroom family units.

Finally, we consider that all the existing mature street trees on the boundary of the car park should be retained and well-managed.  Past neglect should not be a reason for their removal.

Former Southall College Site, Beaconsfield Road, Southall, UB1 1DP

Redevelopment of the site to provide up to seven-storey residential building to accommodate 118 residential units together with associated pedestrian through-access, disabled car parking, cycle storage, private and communal amenity spaces, refuse and recycling storage, and hard and soft landscaping (following demolition of existing buildings)

We objected to this proposed Southall development on grounds of overdevelopment and poor design. The applicant has since offered a small concession by changing five of the 2-bed units to 3‑bed, but offers no other changes in response to our comments.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We consider that the proposal would be overdevelopment.  It would result in a building that would be over tall and over dense.  In addition, we object to the design which appears characterless and lacks association with the area in which it would sit.  In particular, the planned building would be out of keeping with its neighbouring Edwardian and Victorian houses and have an overbearing effect on these and the locally listed Kings Hall.

With respect to the housing accommodation that would be provided, while satisfying minimum space requirements, the planned apartments would not be providing the much needed family accommodation required in this area.  Furthermore, the scheme would provide only limited amenity space with balconies that would be in shadow for most of the day.  For these reasons, this application should be refused.

Land to Rear of 29 Corfton Road, W5 2HP  EALING CRICKET GROUND CONSERVATION AREA

Conversion of an existing single storey building with basement storage into single family dwellinghouse; incorporating basement extension with two front lightwells; part single storey front extension; and provision of associated cycle storage, refuse storage and amenity space

We objected to this backland development in a conservation area on grounds of inappropriate design neither preserving nor enhancing the conservation area. The application has been refused.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We reject the applicant’s assertion that, because planning permission has already been granted for development on this site, permission should be granted for this application.  Instead, the Council must give full consideration to this new application.

Ealing Civic Society objects in principle to backland development due to its propensity to provide poor quality homes in terms of design, access and siting.  This proposed incremental development is no different and, for this reason alone, the application should be refused, as indeed we consider the previous application should have been.  To compound this, in our view, the building design in this latest proposal is of lower quality than the consented scheme.  The site is situated within the Ealing Cricket Ground Conservation Area, and we do not consider that the proposed design would preserve or enhance the area. If, however, the Council is minded to approve the application the flat roof addition should be altered to have a pitched roof and the fenestration should be of a more traditional design so as to be more in keeping with the character of the conservation area.

Wood End Library, Whitton Avenue, UB6 0EE

Construction of a 2 storey, part 3 storey and part 4 storey building to accommodate 11 self-contained flats, a community facility space (Use Class F1) and associated private and communal amenity spaces and landscape and streetscape improvements along Whitton Avenue. (Following demolition of the existing library and children’s centre) (Regulation 3 Application by London Borough of Ealing)

We supported the local residents’ association in objecting to this Council application on grounds of unnecessary demolition, overdevelopment and poor design.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on grounds of its design.  We consider that the proposed building would constitute overdevelopment.  The planned building would be far too tall with bulk and massing that would be inappropriate in this residential location.  In particular, the design of the building would be considerably out of keeping with that of its immediate neighbour, Whitton Court, a 1930s residential block.  We also object to the materials intended in the application – the planned brickwork would not complement that of its neighbours.  Consequently, we recommend that this application does not progress until the Council has sought the advice of their design review panel so that the design, height and massing of any new building on this site are more in keeping with its surroundings.

In addition, we object to the density of the proposed development.  At 377 hr/ha, the density considerably exceeds the guidelines of 150-200 hr/ha in the London Plan density matrix for a suburban location with PTAL of 1b.  Policy 3.4 of the plan sets out that densities in excess of the matrix should be resisted.  In order to achieve this density, the planned building has been situated unacceptably closely to Whitton Court.  Furthermore, the low PTAL value of 1b for this site makes it unsuitable for a no-car development and some on-site provision should be made.  Not least, for safety and practical reasons, the intended disabled space should be provided on-site rather than on-street on this busy road and, if a no-car scheme is progressed, then provision must be made for the inevitable deliveries to site for both residents and the community space.

Finally, we object to the proposed loss of a valuable community facility and its planned replacement with a much smaller and inferior space that would not be adequate to offer the facilities needed by the community.  Instead, we advocate re-use, especially since the existing building was feted as an excellent scheme only a few years ago.  Through a re-use approach, any development on this site would contribute to a reduction in the borough’s carbon emissions rather than an unnecessary and harmful increase caused by demolition and rebuild.

38 Uxbridge Road, W7 3PP  HANWELL CEMETERIES CA

Single storey side/ rear extension; two side dormer roof extensions; installation of cast iron railings and gates to the western boundary; and alterations to the landscaping (following demolition of existing side garage)

We objected to this proposed out-of-character extension to a lodge in the Grade ll listed Westminster Cemetery within a conservation area.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We draw the Council’s attention to the Grade II listing of the whole of Westminster Cemetery which includes the Lodge, the subject of this application.  There is also a separate listing for the gates and railings bordering the Cemetery and the entire site lies within the Hanwell Cemeteries Conservation Area.  Therefore, any development on this site should be treated with the great care afforded to a Grade II listed building and conservation area.  In our view, this care is lacking in this application.  We consider that the minimalist design of the planned extension, together with the proposed dormers to the main front elevation of the building, would be completely inappropriate in this context.  These extensions would be visible from the street and to visitors to the cemetery and significantly detract from heritage of the Cemetery and the Lodge.  Furthermore, the materials proposed are not compliant with the conservation area management plan.  Consequently, this application should be refused.

Long Acre Court, Argyle Road, W13 0DA

Construction of a three storey building to accommodate 6 self-contained flats and provision of associated parking space, cycle storage and refuse storage facilities. (following demolition of existing garages )

We objected to this residential application on grounds of overdevelopment and poor design and the environmental impact of removal of mature trees.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application. We maintain our view in response to the withdrawn application 201412FUL that the principle of residential development on this brownfield site is acceptable.  However, while the scale and design of this latest scheme would be an improvement on the last, the proposed development would still be too dense.  In our view, the external elevations of the planned building would lack interest.  In addition, the proposed materials would cause the building to stand out in comparison with its neighbours, rather than render it in keeping.

Furthermore, once again, the application claims that the homes are designed to lifetime home standards.  However, the proposal is for a three-storey building with no lift.  Apart from the practical difficulties that would result, such as for moving in or out or for bulky deliveries, the lack of a lift means that the development would not meet lifetime homes requirements.  The proposal also continues to require the loss of mature trees which remains unacceptable.

Long Acre Court, Argyle Road, W13 0DA

Construction of third and fourth floor to accommodate 10 self-contained residential units and provision of associated cycle storage,bin store (Prior Approval Application, under Part 20, Class A New Dwellinghouses on detached blocks of flats)

We objected to this application seeking to make use of newly available permitted development rights to add two storeys to an existing block of flats on grounds of a lack of confidence in the quality of the application regarding construction matters, which we felt could suggest a lack of attention to safety.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We draw the Council’s attention to the application’s construction statement which refers to the addition of one storey, not the two which are planned.  This inaccuracy needs to be rectified and any resulting implications arising from it fully addressed.  In addition, we raise concerns about plans to construct third and fourth floor accommodation on a building while the current residents remain in situ.  Not only would this cause practical problems for these residents, and potentially raise safety issues, but the generic nature of the construction statement would not provide them with reassurance that their specific needs would be met during the construction process.

75 St Mary’s Road, W5 5RH  EALING GREEN CA

Conversion of part ground floor and first floor into 6 self-contained flats and associated external alterations

We objected to this proposed conversion of buildings in the conservation area on grounds of significant omissions from the published application, poor quality of the proposed units and damage to the conservation area.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  It has been difficult for us to review fully due to the lack of planning, design & access and heritage statements.  The Council needs to ensure that these are obtained from the applicant and displayed on the Council’s website.

Nevertheless, we have ascertained that the proposed conversion would result in unacceptable overdevelopment.  Four of the planned flats would appear to be below the minimum size standard and there would be no amenity space for future residents.  In addition, we object strongly to aspects of the proposed design.  The site sits within the Ealing Green Conservation Area and is of significant historic interest.  Any development here must, therefore, reflect the character of its surroundings, including the Grade II listed St Mary’s Church, which is an immediate neighbour.  Consequently, the chimney stacks of the building should be retained.  In addition, it is essential that the doors of the old fire station are kept (rather than replaced by a window) and we recommend they be pinned back against the walls to allow the new windows proposed in the application to be inserted without loss of the historic fabric.  The opportunity should also be taken to restore the old ‘Ealing Fire Station’ lettering over the doors which appears to have been obliterated comparatively recently.

The Bungalow Crusaders Memorial House, Blandford Road, W5 5RL

Construction of a three storey five bedroom dwelling house, associated cycle and car parking, refuse storage and amenity space (following demolition of existing bungalow)

We objected to the demolition of this bungalow and the construction of a replacement house which would be too tall for the proposed location. We are trying to establish the history of the bungalow, apparently constructed on the land of the adjacent locally listed Vestry Hall.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We consider that a three storey house on this site would be overdevelopment and significantly out-of-keeping and out of scale with its immediate neighbours.  The applicant is correct that there are three storey properties on this road.  However, due to a bend in the road, these three storey properties are barely visible from this site.  Instead, all the residential properties that surround the site are two storeys in height.

In addition, the drawings of the proposed dwelling house suggest that the second floor windows would be very close to the floor level which may not meet building regulations. It is not possible, In the absence of sectional drawings, to be clear about this aspect which needs to be clarified with the agent/architect.

Overall, in summary, any replacement dwelling house on this site should be two storeys in height.

66 Mattock Lane, W13 9LJ  EALING GREEN CA

Single storey side/rear (wrap around) extension incorporating one rooflight, following demolition of existing rear addition

We objected to this application (one of two – see next application also) for inappropriate extension to one of a group of previously locally listed Victorian cottages in a conservation area.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  The six cottages of which this is one are an important contributor to the character of the Ealing Green Conservation Area.  Any scheme to develop them must, as a minimum, make a positive contribution to this Conservation Area.  Any rear extension to this property would need to respect the precedent set by the other five cottages in this row of six, which this proposal does not.  That is, the planned extension should not exceed the width of the cottage nor extend further back than the rear extensions of its neighbours.  Inclusion of the side extension, which would be visible from the front of the property, interrupts the important open spaces between the pairs of cottages.  In addition, the proposed rear fenestration would be out of keeping with that of this cottage and of its neighbours and detract from their heritage value.  Consequently, this application should be refused.

66 Mattock Lane, W13 9LJ  EALING GREEN CA

First floor rear extension incorporating window to rear elevation

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  The proposed first floor rear extension would be the only first floor extension to any of the cottages in this row of six.  These properties are an important contributor to the character of the Ealing Green Conservation Area (they were formally locally listed but following the review of local heritage assets in 2014 they were inexplicably removed from the local list which we believe to be mistaken). Therefore any scheme to develop them must enhance rather than detract from the character of the Conservation Area, which this proposal does not.  Rather, the proposed extension, together with its fenestration, would diminish the heritage value of these heritage assets.  Furthermore, the proposed extension would be detrimental to the amenity of its neighbours on both sides.  Consequently, this application should be refused.

29-39 Sterling Road and 2-10 Roslin Road, W3 8DJ – W3 8DH

Demolition of existing buildings and construction of a mixed use development comprising commercial floor space (Use Class E(g)) and 149 residential units (Class C3) within two buildings, one being 15 storeys (2-10 Roslin Road) and the other part 11, part 8 and part 2 storeys (29-39 Stirling Road), both with associated landscaping, ancillary and enabling works.

We objected to this revised application where an additional 50% was added to the previously approved application, significantly increasing build on the already overdeveloped site.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment.  We note that the earlier application (192130FUL) has regrettably been approved and thus establishes the principle of this mixed use development on this site, to which we previously objected.  In our objection to that application, we also expressed the view that the then proposed building height would be completely out of scale with that of its immediate neighbours.  This, now taller, scheme worsens this.  In addition, the proposed 50% increase in the number of residential units massively increases the density of an already over-dense development.  There is no precedent for building as high as 15 storeys on this site.  The elaborate ‘outline master plan’ submitted with the application that imagines further developments and the approval of as-yet undetermined applications cannot be used as supporting evidence for the proposals.  These excessive proposals should be refused although some of its design elements could be incorporated to improve the originally approved scheme.

75-117 Boston Road, Hanwell, W7 3SA

The developers of this large site recently distributed a flyer to local residents in which they outlined their proposals to add a further 12 affordable rent homes to this development, which involves the addition of one or two storeys to some blocks. They propose to submit this as a minor amendment. We have responded to them challenging this approach as we consider the changes to be material and to require a full planning application. We also highlight that this is not the first incremental uplift to approved proposals. Should the developer continue to a planning application on this basis, we will formally object.

Ealing Civic Society challenges your intention to submit a proposal to add a further 12 affordable rent homes to the approved scheme as a Section 73 planning application.  The proposals involve the addition of two storeys to the consented scheme; this additional height, with its proposed bulk and massing, constitutes a change to the proposals that would have a material impact on both the consented building and the surrounding area and thus should be submitted through a full planning application.  We also note that this is not the first variation to the originally approved scheme.  This ‘salami slicing’ approach to seeking approval through incremental additions is poor practice and deliberate manipulation of the system that cannot be condoned.