Planning applications: our responses

posted in: Planning | 0

Our environment committee has continued to be extremely busy considering and responding to a growing number of planning applications, including an increasing number of pre-application ‘public consultations’.  Our latest submissions follow, including two responses to these consultations. Do look through them and note the comments about each, which will give you a better understanding of the proposals being put forward and the extent of the threat we are facing to the appearance of our neighbourhoods.

Rear of 57-61 Lea Road, UB2 5QA

Construction of a 4 storey building, a 5 storey building and a 2 storey building, with habitable roof space, to accommodate 46 self-contained flats in total, and provision of associated car parking space, cycle parking space and amenity space. (Following demolition of existing buildings and structures)

We objected to this Southall application, primarily on grounds of over-development.  It remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment.  While we support the principle of developing this site for residential use, we consider the proposed density of this scheme to be far too great for the size of the site.  The planned bulk and massing would be overambitious and the overall height at least one storey too high.  As a result, the surrounding properties and gardens would be inappropriately overlooked causing loss of privacy to existing residents.

Furthermore, we consider the proposed amenity space for residents to be inadequate.  The only green space that is planned would be at the northern end of the site which would lack sunlight.  Finally, there is a shortage of family units in Ealing borough so we would advocate the inclusion of more 3-bedroom units in this development.

69 Oxford Road, W5 5LL

Creation of first floor to accommodate one additional bedroom

We objected to this application in the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area. This is a modern property on the previous site of garages. When permission was granted for its development it was on condition it had only a single storey; this application seeks to remove that constraint. You will see that we have also commented on this ‘incremental’ approach to gaining planning permission. The application, which has attracted 96 objections, remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  The proposed additional floor would be detrimental to the existing property and to at least one of the neighbouring properties.  The amenity space for the existing building at 69 Oxford Road is provided in the basement at its northern end and is thus not ideal in terms of sunlight penetration.  The addition of a first floor would exacerbate this.  Furthermore, the first floor would obstruct daylight entering the basement of the property on The Grove immediately to the south.

More widely, we object to this application because the site sits within the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area.  Any development to this site should respect and enhance the Conservation Area, which this proposal does not.  Rather, the semi-industrial aesthetic of the proposed extra storey, and the extension of the fenestration of the existing building, would significantly detract from the character of the Conservation Area.

Furthermore, while we accept that this is technically allowed, we object strongly to the applicant’s approach of gaining consent for a single storey building and then making a further application to override the attached condition that the building should only be single storey to protect residential amenity.  The requirement for this protection remains and the application should be refused on this basis if no other.

15 Spring Bridge Mews, W5 2AB

Construction of a single storey, with living roof area, offices building (Use Class E(g)), following the demolition of existing building located at 6 to 17 Spring Bridge Mews

In this case, we submitted a neutral comment about this application in the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area, since we saw benefits to the proposals but had some detailed concerns. It remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society supports the principle of this development.  However, we are concerned about the detailed internal design of the proposed units.  We consider that each individual unit should have its own WC facility.  We note that there appears to be discrepancy about this between the submitted plans and paragraph 6.2 in the supporting statement.

London Borough of Ealing, Perceval House, 14-16 Uxbridge Road, W5 2HL

Demolition of existing buildings and phased redevelopment of the site to provide a mixed-use development comprising residential, office, civic/community uses and flexible non-residential floor space, below ground ancillary space (plant, car and cycle parking space, etc.), replacement and relocation of the existing sub-station, associated enabling landscape and public realm works and provision of new pedestrian and vehicle access. (Regulation 3 Application by London Borough of Ealing) (Amended Plans and Additional Documentation).

This application is accompanied by an Environmental Statement required by the Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations, 2017.

The proposals comprise a Major Development that may be likely to affect the character or setting of listed buildings and/or of a Conservation Area.

We responded to a reconsultation on Perceval House; minor changes to materials and drawings had been submitted. We maintained our objections since these cosmetic changes, although an improvement, do not address the many more significant concerns, particularly regarding the height of the tallest block. The application is scheduled to be considered for approval at planning committee on 17th February.

Ealing Civic Society notes the addenda and revised drawings of 9th and 11th December that have been added to the documentation for this application.  We draw the Council’s attention to our strong objections, and those of others, to the original application of September 2020 which these new addenda and drawings do not address.  Most notably, the unacceptable bulk and massing proposed in September’s application would not be addressed by the minor aesthetic changes outlined in the revised documents.  Consequently, we continue to object strongly to this application.

Manhattan Business Park, West Gate, W5 1UP

Request for a Screening Opinion under Regulation 6 of the Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017 for an urban development project comprising demolition of existing B class industrial units (3325sqm) and 10 flats and construction of a mixed-use development ranging between 7 and 13 storeys above podium comprising circa 4074sqm of light industrial floorspace, 2632sqm of new E Class office/employment space, a café (107sqm) and 326 flats with basement and surface

We responded with our usual response to an EIA application; Ealing rarely requires these even for qualifying developments and we consider that they should be submitted. In this case, Ealing again determined that no environmental statement was required.

Ealing Civic Society considers an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) to be essential for this development.  The proposed height and number of residential units, together with the density and massing that would be needed for the proposed uses of the planned development, would have a very significant impact on all aspects of its local environment.

13 Blakesley Avenue, W5 2DN

Conversion of existing dwelling house into 8 self-contained residential units and associated works to the landscape and boundary wall ; Excavation to provide a basement level and provision of lightwells; single storey rear extension; Rear roof extension, and installation of one roof light to front roof slope; Single storey detached garden outbuilding for use as gym/office/garden room

We objected to this application for excessively large extensions and conversion in the Mount Park Conservation Area. It is of note that a similar and smaller scale application for the next-door property has been refused by the Council. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We consider the proposed basement excavation, and above ground extension, would be excessively large.  These developments would also result in an unacceptable loss of garden amenity space.  In addition, the design and fenestration of the planned rear extension would be out of keeping within the Mount Park Conservation Area and with the existing house.  We also raise concerns about the subsidence suffered by many properties in this area due to basement excavations and appeal to the Council to give this subsidence risk due consideration when deciding upon this application.

It is also of note that the Council has already refused a similar, but smaller-scale, application for 15 Blakesley Avenue, the property next door.  In our view, the Council should refuse this application on similar grounds.

15 Blakesley Avenue, W5 2DN

Excavation to provide enlarged basement, single storey rear extension (following demolition of existing rear addition); insertion of window to first floor rear elevation and two glazed, raised lightwells to the front elevation (Retrospective)

This is the neighbouring property, where their application has been refused and an enforcement notice issued to return the property to its previous condition. The applicant has appealed both; we submitted comments to the planning inspectorate suggesting the refusal and enforcement should be upheld. The application remains undetermined.

Response re: 3258722 (lead appeal case). Ealing Civic Society fully supports Ealing Council’s decisions to refuse this application and to carry out enforcement action.  We endorse the view that the proposed works are unacceptable and the harm done by the applicant’s unauthorised works must be remedied as suggested in the enforcement notice.  Therefore, we consider that neither appeal to the Planning Inspectorate for this site should be upheld.

Response to 3259058. Ealing Civic Society fully supports Ealing Council’s decisions to refuse the application under consideration in appeal case 3258722 and to carry out enforcement action (this case 3259058).  We endorse the view that the proposed works are unacceptable and the harm done by the applicant’s unauthorised works must be remedied as suggested in the enforcement notice.  Therefore, we consider that neither appeal to the Planning Inspectorate for this site should be upheld.

A further retrospective application has now been submitted for retention of the basement and a smaller rear extension; we considered that this represented a more reasonable application and have not commented.

Retention of existing basement; completion of rear single storey extension to align with the depth of the existing rear outrigger; insertion of window to first floor rear elevation and two glazed, raised lightwells to the front elevation (part-retrospective)

Land at Rear of 72 The Avenue, W13 8LB

Construction of a two storey dwelling house with basement level and provision of associated private amenity space, cycle parking and refuse storage.

We objected to this application for a modern-design new build property in the rear garden of a property in the St Stephen’s Conservation Area. One application for development in the rear garden has already been granted, in addition to large rear extensions to the original house. This latest proposal represents further overdevelopment and would result in the loss of nearly all the original garden area. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  Firstly, the planned amenity space of 10 sq. m would be significantly below the minimum requirements listed in Ealing Council’s Development Management DPD (2013) of 50 sq. m for a 2-bedroom house and 15 sq. m for a flat.  In addition, the proposed storage space for bicycles in the front hallway is unacceptable and would not, in practice, be retained for this purpose.  Also, the proposed brick colour for the dwelling house would be completely out of keeping with that in the surrounding St Stephen’s Conservation Area.  While we acknowledge that the adjacent property is constructed from the same out-of-keeping bricks as those proposed bricks, we consider that having more of them in this vicinity would detract further from the Conservation Area rather than enhance it.

Ealing Park Tavern, 222 South Ealing Road, W5 4RL

Conversion of part existing public house (Use Class Sui Generis) into 9 self-contained flats (Use Class C3) with associated external alterations involving a three storey rear extension and a first floor two storey side extension (following demolition of existing rear outbuilding) and provision cycle storage and refuse storage

We supported this application for refurbishment and partial conversion to residential use of the Ealing Park Tavern, an interesting but sadly now boarded up pub. The application has been approved (although without taking on board our comments).

Ealing Civic Society supports this application to refurbish and bring back into use the public house.  However, we consider that the South Ealing Road façade should be amended.  We consider that the heavily overhanging eaves detail on the new front gable to South Ealing Road would be awkward and ungainly and recommend that the design is revised to reduce the extent of the overhang.  Ideally the eaves detail would match the existing adjacent gable.  This would in turn permit the balcony railing to return along the sides which would be more elegant and an improvement.

In general, however, we are pleased by the design of the proposed balconies and request that a specific condition be included to ensure that elsewhere the balconies are constructed as they appear in the application, perhaps through approval of details.

51 Carlyle Road & 29A Junction Road, W5 4XP and 29A Junction Road, W5 4XP

Construction of two and three storey building comprising 9 residential units; and provision of associated private amenity areas, cycle parking, landscaping, refuse storage and associated works (following demolition of existing buildings)

Construction of a 3 storey building comprising a nursery (Class E(f)) with associated cycle parking, landscaping, refuse storage and associated works

We were minded to object to both these related applications. The first was approved before our objection had been lodged, and the second has now also been approved.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment.  We consider that the proposed three storey building would be out of keeping with its neighbours which are only two storeys high.  Therefore, one storey should be removed.  In addition, we consider the proposed ‘docklands industrial’ aesthetic to be completely inappropriate in this neighbourhood.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We regret the planned loss of the historic and charming church hall building.  We consider that this building should be retained and ways found to adapt it for use as a nursery, for which it is likely to be very suitable.  The planned 3 storey building would also be out of keeping in this vicinity as it would be a storey higher than the neighbouring buildings, and the design extremely ‘blocky’.  Furthermore the whole area is distinguished by pitched roofs, so the flat roof design would be completely out of character.  Therefore, this application should be rejected.

The Bungalow Crusaders Memorial House, Blandford Road, W5 5RL

Construction of a three storey five bedroom dwelling house, associated cycle and car parking, refuse storage and amenity space (following demolition of existing bungalow)

We submitted further comments to our earlier objection to this application, having established more about the history of the site. We are pleased to note that the application has now been withdrawn.

Further to our objection of 1st December 2020, Ealing Civic Society has learnt that the existing bungalow was built in the 1920s.  Older maps of the area appear to indicate that the bungalow was built on land of its immediate neighbour, Vestry Hall.  Vestry Hall was built in the 1880’s and is locally listed.  We agree with other objectors that a three-storey building on this site would impact very negatively on the setting of Vestry Hall.  Any replacement dwelling house must be in keeping with the design of Vestry Hall and its heritage, which the current bungalow is and this application for the site is not.

Rear of 42 The Grove, W5 5LH

Construction of 6 two-bedroom residential dwelling houses with basement levels and associated landscaping (following demolition of existing garages)

We objected to this application for redevelopment of a backland site currently occupied by garages and builders’ storage on the grounds of overdevelopment and inappropriate design. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We consider the number of houses that are proposed for this small site to be significant overdevelopment.  We also object to the planned design including the bulk, massing and incongruous elevational treatment.  The houses would be too tall.  The proposed materials are unsympathetic to the local area, with concrete an unsuitable material that does not weather well in the English climate.  Both design and materials would render the scheme out of keeping with its neighbours, especially those immediately to the north which sit within the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area.

In addition, we object to the scheme because it would not meet statutory requirements.  The planned basement areas would receive insufficient daylight and, even allowing for the proposed atria, there would be insufficient private amenity space.  The proposed roof terraces would potentially overlook properties and their gardens to the north.  We also have safety concerns since the arguments presented that there would be sufficient space for emergency vehicles in a serious incident are unconvincing.

Furthermore, we have concerns about the environmental integrity of the proposed scheme.  Due to underground water in the area, the basements could present a flood risk.  Furthermore, the planned greenery surrounding the site would present a potential fire and security risk.  We also question the amount of electricity that is predicted to be generated from horizontal photovoltaic panels, which would also be screened from the sun as a result of the proposed planting.  In summary, this application should be rejected.

CP House, 97-107 Uxbridge Road, W5 5TL

Demolition of the existing 12 storey office building, and construction of part 11, part 13 storey office building with flexible uses at ground floor including hard and soft landscaping and all necessary ancillary and enabling works

We objected to this application for demolition and redevelopment of this office site. Comments from the Society and others during the pre-application ‘public consultation’ have not been adequately addressed and were repeated in our objection. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  Our concerns raised at the preliminary public exhibitions have not been adequately addressed.  We object to the bulk of the proposed buildings and their height which we consider would be overbearing on their surroundings; in our view, the buildings should be no taller than the existing buildings on either side.  We also consider the design of the buildings to be uninspiring.  The setback of the top storeys remains insufficient and the sense of an overbearing, monolithic slab at both front and rear of the building would remain.  The buildings would have a negative impact on the neighbouring Ealing Green Conservation Area and historic Walpole Park to the rear.

In addition, we consider that the “boulevard” concept of the Uxbridge Road has been insufficiently maintained, since the proposed colonnade feature intrudes into this space.  Ideally, the frontage of the building should be further set back to better respect the building line.

126 Cavendish Avenue, W13 0JN

Single storey rear extension; alteration to external front elevation involving removal and insertion of windows and door to ground floor flat

We objected to this application to add an extension and make changes to the front of one of a group of similar properties. The application was refused on grounds of the rear extension being overlarge and also the changes at the front being out of keeping with the preserved street scene.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We consider that the proposed changes to the front door and window positions would destroy the important symmetry that exists with the adjoining semi-detached property.  In turn, this would impact very negatively on the harmony and uniformity of all the properties along this street, which share a common appearance.  If permitted, an undesirable precedent would be set for similarly inappropriate changes to other properties.

In addition, since major changes are planned for this property, we would recommend the applicant takes this opportunity to restore the appearance of the original Crittall-style windows, as exhibited by the first-floor maisonette.

Pitzhanger Manor House And Gallery, Mattock Lane, W5 5EQ

Installation of 1 x four sided LED tower (H210.7cm x W93.5cm x D93.5cm – not including plinth); and 5 x mini double sided LED screens with artworks information in front of the manor for a temporary period between 18 March 2021 and 1 August 2021 (H41.4cm x W61.5cm x D23.2cm) (Advertisement Consent)

We considered objecting to this application on the grounds that the proposed installation at the front of the Manor House would impact negatively on the setting of the listed building. Having clarified the proposed position of the structure, we concluded that since it was only temporary and considering the need to do all possible to encourage visitors when allowed back to the property, we would not comment. The Ealing Green Conservation Area panel has since lodged an objection and the application remains undetermined.

37-39 North Acton Road, NW10 6PF

Outline planning permission with the details of access, appearance, landscaping, layout and scale reserved for later determination for demolition and redevelopment to comprise a data centre (Use Class B8) of up to 25,000 sqm gross external, including ancillary offices, internal plant and equipment(including flues), and substation. In addition to the above the Development may also include: car parking; car parking; provision of external plant and equipment(including flues) and fuel storage; creation of servicing areas and provision of associated services, including waste, refuse, cycle storage, and lighting; and for the laying out of the buildings; routes and open spaces within the development; and all associated and ancillary works and operations including but not limited to to: demolition; engineering operations. Development shall be in accordance with the approved Development Parameters Schedule and Plans.(Consultation from OPDC)

This outline application for a proposed data centre is in the Park Royal area of the borough where OPDC is the planning authority. The proposed development is a very large industrial building on the edge of a green open space. We submitted an objection on grounds of the overbearing nature of the proposals.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We consider that the proposed monolithic block would overwhelm the setting of the adjacent open space and also have a deleterious impact upon the nearby residential properties.  Any outline consent granted for the scheme should specify that the unit should be split into smaller blocks in order to be more sympathetic to the open space and residential surroundings.  The proposed green walls and screening planting should also be mandated.

Chasholl, Sutherland Road, W13 0DT

Construction of third and fourth floor to accommodate 3 self-contained residential units (Prior Approval Application, under Part 20, Class A New Dwellinghouses on detached blocks of flats)

We objected to this application on design grounds and because of the inadequate amenity space. Unfortunately, the applicant has taken advantage of recently introduced permitted development rights to seek approval for these proposals. This means that the Council cannot refuse the application provided certain criteria are met, and also that otherwise reasonable grounds for objection, such as design matters and amenity space provision, cannot be taken into consideration. It appears that this application is to be approved.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  The original building was clearly designed with sensitivity to the surrounding area and would have gained consent based on its appearance and massing.  We note that approval has already been given to a single-storey extension and would not object to the proposal to create an extra storey in the roof which, through the addition of dormers, would maintain this appearance.  However, we strongly object to the planned creation of a 2nd additional storey to be created by raising the height of the walls.  In our view, this 2nd additional storey would completely change the proportions of the building which we consider very important to the integrity of the original design.  The consequent loss of cornice and overall design would render the resulting building significantly out of keeping with its surrounding area.

In addition, the available amenity space is insufficient for the proposed units.  For two of these flats, no new amenity space is proposed; the communal space is already small.  Furthermore, the development would exceed guideline density levels – the officer’s report on the approved extension noted that one additional flat resulted in marginally exceeded density levels; the granting of three flats would significantly exacerbate this situation.

Land Rear of Park Parade, W3 9BD

Redevelopment of backland site behind 1-14 Park Parade and 1-11 Lillian Avenue to provide five, two storey dwelling houses with pedestrian access point from Park Parade including associated landscaping, amenity space, refuse and cycle storage

This is the latest in a series of applications for this site following withdrawal or refusal of earlier applications. We have again objected on grounds of overdevelopment. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  As with previous applications for this site, we object on the grounds of overdevelopment.   We consider that the proposed five, two storey dwelling houses would be far too cramped on this site.  By attempting to squeeze five units into this small space, the houses in this application would not comply with space standards and would have insufficient amenity space.  In addition, the proposed houses would overlook the gardens to the rear of properties in the adjoining Lillian Avenue, which would seriously affect the amenity of residents.  Furthermore, the environs of the proposed units would be very unsatisfactory given their proximity to the retail servicing area behind the shops. Furthermore, the proposal would inevitably lead to unresolvable problems with access to the site such as for refuse collection and emergency vehicles. 

135 Uxbridge Road, W13 9AU

Construction of a four storey building to provide commercial unit and six self-contained residential units (1 x 1 bed; 6 x studio); incorporating roof terraces and balconies; associated amenity space, refuse and cycle storage (following demolition of existing buildings

We objected to this application on grounds of unsuitable overdevelopment.  It remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment.  We consider that the ground floor of this building is unsuitable for residential use as the planned ground floor residential unit would be far too close to adjoining properties, would suffer from very poor daylight, be overlooked and be far too close to the proposed position of waste and recycling containers. The ground floor should be maintained for commercial use only; this would also permit the commercial unit to be of a more adequate size.  We also object to the inclusion of the fourth floor on the grounds that the proposed building would be out of keeping with its immediate neighbours to the rear, which are 2 storeys in height.  The additional floors, despite the proposed set-back from the frontage, would also be visible above and destroy the consistency of the 2-storey terrace of retail units.

64 Clovelly Road, W5 5HE

Conversion of existing building into 5 self-contained flats; incorporating basement extension; single storey rear extension; part single, part two and part three-storey side extension (following demolition of existing side annexe and garage); rear roof extension; conversion of loft space into habitable space; creation of terraces/balconies at first and second floor levels; installation of five rooflights to front roofslopes; internal and external alterations; and provision of associated private amenity space, landscaping, and refuse storage

We objected to this second application for development of this site, following the withdrawal of a previous proposal to which we also objected. Although an improvement, the proposal still represents overdevelopment of an inappropriate design that would have a negative impact on Lammas Park. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application on the grounds of overdevelopment.  The proposed extension ‘mirroring’ the original property is acceptable, and, taking into account other comments below, would still allow the creation of four flats offering good living conditions and without inappropriate overdevelopment.  We consider the proposed further side extension to be excessive and to be incompatible with the general architecture of the street; there should remain a gap between the new property and the southern boundary of the site, which adjoins Lammas Park.  In our view, the planned design of the rear extensions would be inappropriate for the surrounding area and the view from Lammas Park.  Although the houses backing on to Lammas Park have been modified with loft and rear extensions of varied designs, none has been so extensively and inappropriately modified.  In particular, the proposed flat roofs and terraces would be out of keeping with neighbours – the design should instead incorporate a pitched roof.  The rear extensions should also not project further into the rear gardens than the existing returns.  In addition, we note that concerns have been raised by residents with local knowledge about the inclusion of a basement extension in this location subject to high levels of ground water, and that the Council’s earlier advice was that no basement should be included.  While we are not qualified to comment on the submitted technical report that claims that any risks could be mitigated, this is not based on local knowledge and such inclusion should be rejected.

Kemsley Court, Rathgar Avenue, W13 9PP

Construction of part fourth floor and part fifth floor to create five self-contained flats; refurbishment/extension of existing stair cores to provide access to new upper floor units; associated hardstanding and external cycle and waste storage enclosures

We had previously objected to this application, which has now been slightly modified to include balconies to the new flats. We did not object to this modification, which in fact improved the appearance, but reiterated our objection to the proposed increased height. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We have no specific comment on the planned additional balconies.  However, we maintain our objection to the proposed increase in height of the building and reiterate our previous comments in response to this application.  We consider that the increase in height of the building would result in overdevelopment and resulting development would dominate the surrounding area, which is predominantly of 2 and 3 storeys in height.  This would also have a detrimental impact on the adjacent Ealing Green Conservation Area immediately to the north.

Karma Nightclub, 10 High Street, W5 5DB

Change of use from nightclub (Use Class Sui Generis) to a mixed use venue including event/music space, cinema, drinking establishment/bar, food kiosk and cafe (Mixed Use, Classes Sui Generis and E) and associated internal and external alteration involving the creation of part mezzanine level and new shopfront/entrances

This application relates to premises in the Ealing Broadway Centre, which lies within the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area, previously nightclub Karma and pole dancing club LA Confidential. The Centre’s landlords have secured a new tenant and this application relates to the change of use of the premises, internal alterations to include cinema provision and improvements to the external appearance. We welcome these changes and supported the application. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society supports this application.  We support the bringing back into use of a currently empty site with a history of problems as a venue that would provide an interesting and useful addition to the town centre.  The proposed new cinema screens would contribute positively to the Town Centre night-time economy offering.

1A & 3 The Mall, W5 2PJ

Construction of a ten storey building to provide 81 units consisting of co-living accommodation (Use Class Sui Generis) including shared communal areas and kitchens, terrace area, cycle spaces and refuse / recycling storage area

We objected to this latest in a series of applications for this site in the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area. The site has existing consent for an eight-storey building for 71 co-living units and this further proposal merely compounds the problems we previously objected to. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  While we welcome in this application some improvement to the size of a few of the planned units and facilities, we categorically object to the proposed additional storeys and units.  These proposals would exacerbate the negative impact on the Ealing Town Centre Conservation Area of the already consented scheme for this site.  We reiterate our view in response to this previous application that a building that would be higher than that of the adjacent Grade II listed NatWestBank would be too high.  The consented scheme, with 8 storeys, would already be too visible and over dominant in its surroundings; 10 storeys would amplify this effect.  In addition, we maintain our strong concern that the proposed units would not comply with nationally adopted space standards, resulting in too great a density and insufficient facilities.

Land Rear of 7 Montpelier Road, W5 2QP

Construction of single storey two bedroom dwellinghouse; and provision of associated amenity space, refuse and cycle storage (following demolition of existing garage)

This is a second application for a proposed back garden development in the Montpelier Park Conservation Area. The previous application was refused but we continue to object to this backland development. The application remains undetermined.

ECS objects to this application

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  In line with our response to the previous application for this site, we object in principle to backland development.  The siting of the proposed new property would be inappropriate in planning terms due to its boxy design which would be out of keeping with the conservation area and the impact it would have on the amenity of neighbouring residents.  In addition, access to the proposed dwelling house would be poor, particularly for emergency services.  If, however, the Council was minded to grant this application, it would need to ensure that the development was compliant with all the requirements for a new housing unit which, at present, this scheme does not appear to be.

70 Hanger Lane, W5 2JH

Part three, part four, part five, part six-storey building with two basement levels to form a fifty-nine room, fifty-nine person large house in multiple occupation (HMO) (Use Class Sui Generis); and associated amenity, cycle parking, waste storage, and vehicle parking spaces (following demolition of existing buildings) (Amended Proposal)

We previously objected to this application on several grounds including the proposed use, encroachment on to Metropolitan Open Land, bulk and massing. The proposed development has now, with no explanation, been increased in height to accommodate additional units, compounding the problems. We are minded to submit the following objection, but are awaiting comment from the planning officer (who so far has not responded) on the justification for these changes in the light of significant objection to the original proposals. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this revised application.  We reiterate our comments in response to the original submission.  We continue to contest that the development qualifies as sui generis use class.  Instead, it should be treated as a C3 residential use and, therefore, meet the policy requirements for residential uses in the Local Plan.  In addition, we maintain our opposition to a development of this size on Metropolitan Open Land.  We elaborate on these points in our first response.  The increase in size of the development outlined in the new application documents would exacerbate the inappropriateness of this scheme, which should be refused.

Rear of 1 Golden Manor, W7 3EE

Construction of a single storey detached dwellinghouse, including basement with access fronting onto Alwyne Road; provision of associated landscaping and amenity space, refuse and cycle storage

We objected to this latest application for a back garden development in the Hanwell Village Green Conservation Area, which would be damaging to the Conservation Area. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this application.  We object to the planned construction of a dwelling house in the rear garden of 1 Golden Manor.  The run of large rear gardens of the properties of Golden Manor contributes to the character of the Hanwell Village Green Conservation Area in which they sit.  Erecting a building in the garden of 1 Golden Manor would destroy this run.  The proposals are in no way comparable to any historic building on the site; it is clear from map extracts and the width (less than 1m) of the old pavement crossover that there has only ever been a very small building (possibly a shed) on this site.  The proposed footprint of the building takes up the majority of the garden space of 1 Golden Manor, leaving insufficient amenity space for both the host property and also any future residents of the proposed building.  Furthermore, the site is opposite the Churchfields Conservation Area and sits within the setting of the nearby Grade I listed Wharncliffe Viaduct.  It is important that any development in this vicinity is in keeping with this characterful area, which this scheme is not.  For all these reasons, this application should be refused in line with earlier applications to develop this site.

75-117 Boston Road, Hanwell, W7 3SA

Minor Material Amendment (S73) to vary conditions 2, 15, 16, 22, 25, 26, 27 and 32, seeking to increase the number of residential units, in pursuant to planning permission ref: 191309FUL approved 18/09/2020, as varied by application re: 204633NMA (approved 09/12/2020) for: Demolition of existingbuildings and development of 3 blocks comprising studio, one, two, three and four bed flats, ground floor retail / non-residential institution / assembly & leisure and commercial units; with vehicle access fromAdelaide Road, servicing, car and cycle parking, refuse storage, landscaping, public and private amenityspace, and village square open space

This is the latest of a number of amendments that have been submitted since consent was granted for this large development in Hanwell, each increasing the size and number of units. In this case, we had already advised the applicant that we felt the use of a S73 amendment to be inappropriate; we have objected to the formal application on the same grounds. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects to this Section 73 application, which involves the addition of two extra storeys on one building and one storey on another.  This planned additional height, with its proposed bulk and massing, constitutes a change to the original scheme that would have a material impact on both the consented buildings and the surrounding area.  Consequently, this application should be submitted as a full application rather than a Section 73 application.

We also note that this is not the first variation to the originally approved scheme.  This ‘salami slicing’ approach to seeking approval through incremental additions is poor practice and deliberate manipulation of the system that should not be condoned by the planning authority.

Barbara Speake Stage School, East Acton Lane, W3 7EG

Demolition of existing building and construction of a 5-storey building with basement accommodation for plant equipment fronting East Acton Lane and a 4-storey building to rear of site comprising 38 self-contained residential dwellings (Use Class C3), including associated communal external amenity space, landscaping, plant equipment, refuse and bicycle stores, and associated works

We submitted a comment on this application, broadly welcoming the proposals but with some reservations. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society is neutral about this application.  We welcome the sensitivity with which the accommodation within this proposed building has been designed.  However, we are concerned about the impact of the building on the adjacent East Acton Court, whose residents would lose daylight as a result.  The Council should be satisfied the East Acton Court residents would not suffer significant adverse effects before granting this application.

36 High Street, Acton, W3 6LG

Construction of fourth floor to a main building; internal and external alterations to existing building including roof alterations; construction of attached six storey building with basement excavation to create additional 7 No. residential units (total of 17 residential units); and provision of associated refuse and cycle storage

We objected to this application in the Acton Town Centre Conservation Area. We had objected to the previous application for this site, which was granted; this further application would create an over-tall building with unsympathetic infill detailing. The application remains undetermined.

Ealing Civic Society objects strongly to this application.  We object to the planned change in fenestration to the infill building – the consented fenestration is currently in keeping with the main characterful Victorian house (formerly the headquarters of a local funeral stonemasons company) but the synergy would be lost if this change were to be permitted.  In addition, we object to the planned additional storey to the main house which would completely destroy its  original proportions and result in an ungainly appearance.  Finally, we object to the planned height of the six storey infill building, which would be above the adjacent building at Zero Alfred Road.  This would render the new six storey building incongruous in its surroundings.  For these reasons, this application should be refused.

Pre-application consultations

The Society has also responded to two pre-application public ‘consultations’.  While we welcome the greater efforts being made by some applicants to engage with the community prior to submitting a planning application, this does seem to be more of a ‘tick box’ exercise so that they can say that they have done this rather than a genuine attempt to establish and then respond to the views of the local community.  Changes are rarely made in response to concerns, or are minimal and do not address the real issues.  The same points then need to be made in response to the application when submitted.

Kenmore Mansions, 111-153 Pitshanger Lane, W5 1RJ

In summary, the applicants propose the addition of two additional storeys to Kenmure Mansions, flats above shops on the south side of Pitshanger Lane.  We, and  any local residents, objected to an earlier application, which was withdrawn, supposedly for further (actually in this case, some) public engagement.  The scheme now being ‘consulted’ on is identical to the withdrawn and widely disliked scheme.  We will be repeating our concerns.

1 Pitshanger Lane, W5 1RH

Here, the proposals are to demolish an existing 2-storey care home in a predominantly low-rise neighbourhood and replace it with a modernistic up to eight-storey block of flats.  When first advised of these proposals we fed back to the developer that the proposals were totally unacceptable and advised them that there would be significant local objection if they went ahead.  This view was echoed by the local residents’ and traders’ associations.  However, the developer has pressed ahead with a public ‘consultation’ exercise on exactly the same proposals, which we anticipate will not be any more favourably received when the wider community is involved.  We will be reiterating our concerns.